Rent vs. Own: What's The Best Option For You

Sydney Winstead • April 4, 2025

Should You Rent or Own? A Real-World Breakdown on a $1M Home

Presented by Real Estate Novo


Get in touch with us today about our upcoming exclusive rent vs. own seminar!


The question of whether to rent or buy isn’t just philosophical—it’s financial. For anyone considering a $1,000,000 home, the stakes are real and the math matters. Let’s break it down with actual numbers, tax implications, and long-term outcomes so you can make the decision that’s right for you.

Monthly Cost Comparison:

Let’s say you’re eyeing a $1,000,000 home.

If You Buy:

  • Down Payment (20%): $200,000
  • Loan Amount: $800,000
  • Interest Rate: 6.5% (30-year fixed)
  • Monthly Principal & Interest: ~$5,056
  • Property Taxes (1.25%): ~$1,042/month
  • Homeowners Insurance: ~$100/month
  • Maintenance Budget (1% annually): ~$833/month

 Total Monthly Cost (before tax benefits)~$7,031

If You Rent a Comparable Home:

  • Rent: ~$4,500/month
  • Renters Insurance: ~$20/month

 Total Monthly Rent Cost~$4,520


Surface-Level Comparison:
Renting
appears to be ~$2,500/month cheaper—but that’s before factoring in tax savings, equity build-up, and appreciation.


Tax Benefits of Homeownership:

Mortgage interest and property taxes are often tax-deductible if you itemize your deductions (subject to IRS limits and qualifications).


Estimated First-Year Deductions:

  • Mortgage Interest (Year 1): ~$51,000
  • Property Taxes: ~$12,500
  • Total Deductible Expenses~$63,500


If you're in a 35% combined federal and state tax bracket, that could result in tax savings of  ~$22,225/year, or about $1,850/month.


Adjusted Monthly Cost (after tax benefits):
$7,031 - $1,850 = $5,181/month

👉🏼 Now the cost of buying is much closer to renting.


Equity Accumulation

Your monthly mortgage payment builds ownership, not just covers housing.

  • Year 1 Loan Paydown (Principal): ~$13,000
  • Estimated Home Appreciation (3%/year): ~$159,000 after 5 years
  • Loan Paydown After 5 Years: ~$75,000

 Total Equity After 5 Years: ~$234,000

Compare that to renting for 5 years at $4,500/month with 3% annual increases: you'd spend over $290,000 in rent, with no ownership to show for it.


Flexibility vs. Responsibility

Renting Offers:

  • Greater mobility
  • Lower upfront costs
  • No maintenance concerns
  • But: rising rents, no equity, and no tax savings

Buying Offers:

  • Long-term wealth building
  • Stability and control
  • Potential tax benefits
  • But: higher upfront investment, market exposure, and ongoing responsibility


💭 Final Thought from Real Estate Novo

The best decision depends on your goals, lifestyle, and time horizon. But when you factor in tax benefits, equity, and appreciation, buying can often outpace renting in the long run—even when the monthly cost seems higher at first.


At Real Estate Novo, we’re here to help you explore your options with clarity and confidence. Whether you're a first-time buyer, long-time renter, or simply curious about the numbers—we’ll walk through the scenarios and guide you toward the right fit for your future.


Let’s connect. Reach out anytime for a one-on-one conversation.
 
Contact Here


📩 Get in touch with us today about our upcoming exclusive rent vs. own seminar!



Disclaimer:  Real Estate Novo does not provide tax or legal advice. The figures and scenarios presented in this article are estimates for informational purposes only. Tax deductions and mortgage terms vary based on individual circumstances. Before making any purchase decision, please consult your tax advisor and mortgage lender to confirm what applies to your specific situation.


By Sydney Winstead October 24, 2025
Your Weekly Dose of San Diego
By Sydney Winstead October 23, 2025
Weekly Roundup in SF
By Sydney Winstead October 16, 2025
Inherited a Property in San Diego but Live Out of State? Here’s What to Do Next
By Sydney Winstead October 1, 2025
San Diego Neighborhood Guide — rental trends, housing insights, lifestyle highlights, and our agents’ picks for the best places to eat & drink.
By Jackson Salamunovich September 30, 2025
Celebrating Our Wonderful Community Learn more about AMSI's amazing team...
By Sydney Winstead September 17, 2025
Discover the Best Fall Activities in San Francisco: Pumpkin Patches, Apple Picking, Outdoor Adventures & Seasonal Fun
By Sydney Winstead September 17, 2025
Restaurants Opening Theirs Doors This Fall in San Francisco
By Sydney Winstead September 16, 2025
Recipe of the Season: Butternut Squash & Sage Risotto with Rosemary & Apple Cider Spritz
By Sydney Winstead September 11, 2025
Built in the Bay: Tracking San Francisco’s Growth and Transformation
By Sydney Winstead August 14, 2025
San Francisco Real Estate 2025: Housing Prices, Interest Rates, and Rental Rules to Watch